The student news site of West High School

West Side Story

94

Following a list that sparked school-wide discontent for its ratings on the appearances of 94 female students on Oct. 18, many gathered to make posters spreading positive messages and empowering women.

Posters+were+made+in+response+to+the+list+that+had+been+sent+out+days+earlier+by+students.+
Posters were made in response to the list that had been sent out days earlier by students.

Posters were made in response to the list that had been sent out days earlier by students.

Fatima Kammona

Fatima Kammona

Posters were made in response to the list that had been sent out days earlier by students.

94 personalities. 94 smiles. 94 women who have family and friends. 94 women who have feelings. 94 women who were objectified. 94 women who were graded. 94 names.

On the morning of Oct. 20, students and faculty at Iowa City West High School gathered in room 132 to respond to a list that had graded women’s appearances, most of them juniors.  The group made posters and hung them up around the school.“[We wanted to] promote the message of positive and female empowerment that is so necessary in light of recent events,” said Madeleine Roberts-Ganim ’19.

The list began to circulate a few days earlier. “I heard about it Wednesday afternoon,” Megan Johnson, a social studies teacher and organizer of the meeting Friday morning, said. “One of my students had actually come in to get some help with AP Psychology and I could tell that they were upset about something … When I first heard about it, I was shocked but not surprised, unfortunately.”

The reaction was almost identical of that of student and creator of #EveryonesAnA Lucy Polyak ’19. “I remember being disappointed but not surprised,” Polyak said. “I wasn’t on the list but I did create the hashtag. People are just so upset right now. I’m upset, my friends are upset, people I hardly know are upset and I feel for them. I was like, ‘You know what? There has to be a way to bring joy to people again because even in the darkest of times, there’s always light to be found.”

One name on that list belonged to Lauren Upchurch ’19, “When I first found out about the list, I was disgusted,” Upchurch said. “I looked at that list and people I’ve known for years … were graded based on their looks … For many years I struggled with insecurities about looks, about weight. And it got to the point of me crying to my parents and they just told me, ‘What about those people is so important to you when they say this stuff? Like why does their opinion get to hurt you?’”

Posters were made in response to the list that had been spread around days earlier by students.

Fatima Kammona

“I’m more than just a letter.” said Upchurch “Personally me being graded a ‘C’ doesn’t affect me but the fact that I have friends who still feel these awful insecurities every single day of their lives see it on paper, it [can] just crush somebody.”

Upon entering the room, the outrage of what happened could be felt. However, a feeling of pride also permeated the space. “I really think we have to focus on … crushing this misogynistic and sexist behavior,” Roberts-Ganim said. “The boys who created this list were trying to exert some level of control and authority over women [because] they don’t feel like they have that in real life.  I think we have to take the power back and it’s so amazing to be in a room full of wonderful, powerful women who are all supporting each other and getting through it together.” Roberts-Ganim said.

Though the room was filled mostly by female students and faculty, Samer Suleman ’18 participated in making posters. “I knew that this was a time when people need us to bind together to show our positivity [and] support for people who are wronged”, Suleman said. “If anything, I like to be the example … that there is good in the world. There are people who aren’t out to just selfishly harm others, and if it means me just getting up a little earlier and going to a room to make posters to spread positive around the world, then that’s something I would like to do.”

Though it’s been  almost two weeks now  some believe that this incident shouldn’t be forgotten,“I don’t think we should move on. . . not like the center of attention or anything but if you forget about it it’s like brushing it off. It’s like letting those people who created such things. . . Never forget about because it can always be an example for you to know that there’s room for growth.” said Suleman.

“There is not somebody on that list beautiful inside and out,” said Lucy Polyak ’19 in response to the list.

With all the negativity that surrounded the list, there’s still hope for a positive outcome. “I think one of the most important things that we can learn is that what a few high school boys do or say doesn’t really matter in the grand scheme of things,” Johnson said. “ We’re . . . so much stronger and more powerful when we all come together… I feel like [these signs] will be a reminder to people that what happened was the work of just a few people here and it’s not what most people feel. We can take the power out of [the list].”

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






1 Comment

One Response to “94”

  1. Megan Johnson on November 2nd, 2017 10:02 pm

    Fatima, you did an amazing job with this article! And I hope we can all come together to spread some positivity again sometime soon!

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Right
Navigate Left
  • 94

    Breaking

    Liberty High closed due to threat

  • 94

    News

    Theatre West is a-changing

  • 94

    Breaking

    10 seniors sign National Letters of Intent

  • 94

    Breaking

    ICCSD technology department says Chromebook update is unintentional

  • 94

    News

    The Mueller investigation

  • 94

    Breaking

    Why are the Chromebooks logging out?

  • 94

    Metro

    SSIKED hosts annual Diversity Dinner

  • 94

    Breaking

    Back parking lot floods, water at West turned off

  • 94

    Metro

    Spooky strings scare up over $2,000

  • 94

    Breaking

    Finals schedule released for end of first trimester

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






The student news site of West High School
94