Effectiveness of sexual assault prevention education questioned
Many high schools across Iowa, including Iowa City West, have varieties of sexual assault prevention education. But what are these classes actually doing to combat this issue?
April 29, 2017
Attempts to educate students about sexual assault in a high school setting sometimes lack effectiveness, IowaWatch interviews with teachers, administrators and high school students from 18 Iowa school districts revealed.
The result is students who said they didn’t know what sexual assault consisted of, how to prevent it and how to get help after an assault took place.
The interviews revealed that the problem stems, in part, from too little time for the topic when so many things need to be covered in health classes. In some schools, the education is only in ninth grade, a time before most students become sexually active, educators said in the IowaWatch interviews. In other schools, education is not provided at all.
“I have had to go out and do my own research on it, and that shouldn’t be the case,” Harley Atchison, 17, a junior at Pella High School, said. She said she has no memory of any sexual assault prevention education in school. “For how large of a problem sexual assault is, there is nothing being done about it early on. Many girls especially are not aware of the dangers they will be exposed to once they leave the comfort of their own home.”
Curriculum among school districts varies because it is chosen at the local, not state, level, Staci Hupp Ballard, Iowa Department of Education communications director, said.
“A school’s curriculum decision is approved by its school board or authorities in charge,” Hupp Ballard said. “The Iowa Department of Education’s role is to ensure districts are providing the required courses and to provide resource links for school districts or schools to access,” she said.
Des Moines Valley High School Principal Tim Miller said, “We do not have a course in place that has curriculum specifically tied to sexual assault.” Reasons include not having time or course material, he said.
THE UNSPOKEN TOPIC
Rape and sexual violence are commonly known abuses on college and high school campuses, according to RAINN, the Rape Abuse & Incest National Network. About 70 percent of all sexual assault cases happen to children ages 17 and under. More than 42 million adults were sexually assaulted before the age of 18, information released by the Children’s Assessment Center shows.
More education about sexual assault would teach young people about healthy relationships, break stereotypes and expose people to what sexual violence really is, Kathryn Rittenhour, a Rape Victim Advocacy Program volunteer in Iowa City, said. Rittenhour, a University of Iowa graduate student in the Department of Sociology, speaks frequently in Iowa City-area schools about rape and assault prevention.
“Then students may be able to assist someone who has been a victim of sexual violence or they could be able to recognize what abuse and violence looks like in their own lives,” she said.
That kind of knowledge would have helped one Eastern Iowa high school junior who said she was sexually assaulted and who consented to being interviewed by IowaWatch if her name was not used. IowaWatch confirmed that her case was turned over to police and agreed not to identify her because she is minor and because of the nature of what happened.
The student said her body shut down and froze and that she didn’t know what to do when she was assaulted in November 2015. She received counseling from rape victim advocates.
“They talked to me about it and helped me understand that it wasn’t my fault that I froze, because I blamed myself for so long,” she said. “That is what people don’t understand. They don’t realize how it happens. A lot of people think that you have to be in a dark alley or be drunk for you to be sexually assaulted, and that’s not true.”
Rittenhour said these misconceptions about sexual violence are common among Iowa high school students and teachers.
“A lot of young people don’t have much exposure to education about healthy relationships and sexual violence,” Rittenhour said. “And unfortunately there are a lot of myths and stereotypical images in media which get perpetuated in schools and classroom that can be really harmful. This can create some negative betrayals of what relationships look like for teenagers, making sexual assault a huge problem in high school settings.”
Cecilia Roudabush, a health teacher at North Central Junior High School in North Liberty in the Iowa City school district, said media such as demeaning music lyrics and videos should not be teaching children about sexual assault. She points to videos portraying women ogled by men, which she shows in class in order to make a point with students.
“They don’t realize what some of the material is promoting,” she said.
Kathryn Herdliska, 17, a Cedar Rapids Prairie High School junior, said drilling into students that sexual assault is not okay could help assault victims know they are not alone.
“They need to know that they have support and they need to know what to do next,” Herdliska said. “So many sexual assault victims go unnoticed and so many cases aren’t put into action and it’s really sad.”
Education is aimed at boys as well as girls. But Prairie High student Andre Vongpanya, 16, said he doesn’t know if he could have benefited from more attention to sexual assault prevention in class. The reason, the junior said, is that he has been given little to no education about the topic.
“The only education we ever got was a one-day presentation in ninth grade,” he said.
Taylor Grider, 16, an Iowa City West High School junior said she took one trimester of health during her freshman year but that seemed like a minimal amount considering that she was going to high school for four years.
“I don’t think we even really touch the subject of assault that much. I don’t even remember talking about it,” Grider said.
Students are not the only ones who think this. West High health teacher Kathy Bresnahan said sexual assault should be brought up in more than just freshman health class.
“Juniors and seniors need to hear about it at their age much more,” Bresnahan said. “The downfall of this curriculum is that it is just for ninth graders and there is so much health information to go over. And everything is important but we have such little time.”
Brooke Timmerman, 18, a senior at Cedar Rapids Kennedy High School, said she fears that minimal education makes students more vulnerable to sexual abuse.
“When students aren’t educated on sexual assault they feel lost when it happens to them or a friend; they don’t know exactly what it is, how to stop it, and how to report it,” she said.
A LACK OF UNDERSTANDING
“I honestly never really knew what a sexual assault was, or what you would consider an act of sexual assault,” said Sydnie, another Eastern Iowa high school junior who said she was sexually abused at her school in a place where cameras did not exist. IowaWatch chose not to use her full name in this story.
“Now, if one of my friends or family members, or even just an acquaintance, would come up to me and say something happened, I would urge them to tell someone right away. I kept mine hidden for a long time, and it only made things worse.”
She eventually reported the incident to school officials and police.
After her incident, Sydnie began to notice that many of her peers didn’t understand sexual assault. “I heard this one guy say, ‘He touched her butt, I bet she’s going to turn him in for sexual assault now.’ They don’t understand how serious it is, and that it is more than just that.”
HOW SOME DISTRICTS RESPOND
Despite concerns about sexual assault prevention education, several Iowa school administrators IowaWatch interviewed said the amount of education is right where it needs to be.
Many Iowa districts share a partnership with the University of Northern Iowa Center for Violence Prevention, implementing a program called Mentors in Violence Prevention (MVP). The districts include Sioux City, Cedar Rapids, Marshalltown and Cedar Falls school districts.
Jen Gomez, director of student services and equity education in the Sioux City Community School District, said each school in that district has trained adult advisors who teach various lessons to ninth grade students, typically through an Advisory/Homework block.
This year, the district’s health teachers hosted a viewing of Audrie & Daisy for all ninth grade students. This movie follows two teenage girls through being sexually assaulted to dealing with the harassment of fellow students, eventually leading to attempted suicide.
“After the viewing, school counselors, mental health therapists and domestic violence and sexual assault specialists and advocates led small group discussions with the students,” Gomez said.
Marshalltown Community School District Superintendent Theron Schutte said MVP students in that district talk about situations that could lead to sexual assault. The discussion includes setting boundaries and what to do when someone crosses them, he said.
“We talk a lot about values, pressure situations and what to do in the event that those things happen,” Schutte said.
In the Cedar Falls district, a partnership with the Riverview Center in Waterloo, another program influencing the education of sexual assault, uses a program called Safe Dates in junior high and high schools. Dan Conrad, Cedar Falls district’s director of secondary education, said the program is used during one class period monthly to discuss “consent, healthy relationships and positive decision-making.”
Other districts that are not involved with MVP are making strides addressing sexual violence, said Bruce Amendt, associate superintendent of the Johnston Community School District. A law enforcement officer talks with students once a year in health classes about what to do if assault occurs.
“As part of the health curriculum, a law enforcement officer provides learning related to safety including what to do if inappropriate dialogue, contacts and situations occur,” Amendt said.
Administrators at other school districts who were interviewed said they are not able to spend a lot of time on assault prevention education.
“Classes are only one trimester, so we are not able to allocate a lot of time to assault, but do try to have a couple of lessons on it,” Sue Chelf, health curriculum coordinator in the Iowa City school district, said.
Lora Daily, Iowa City school district director of learning supports, said, “We know it affects students in our schools, and we will continue to review our curriculum, provide ongoing staff training and utilize local experts such as the RVAP (Iowa City’s Rape Victim Advocacy Program).”
Students who were interviewed said they are advocating for improvement of their school’s curriculum so that it teaches sexual assault prevention.
Cedar Rapids Kennedy High School’s Timmerman said passing Erin’s Law in Iowa would help. This law, promoted by childhood sexual assault survivor Erin Merryn, would require that all public schools in Iowa provide a program for sexual assault prevention education. Iowa is among 17 states where legislation adopting the law has been introduced but not passed.
“It would give educators resources on how to teach about sexual assault, and it would create an environment that is more vigilant towards sexual assault,” Timmerman said
Talking would be the first choice of the Eastern Iowa student who agreed to talk with IowaWatch about being assaulted in November 2015. “After my assault, I didn’t feel comfortable at school, a place where I was supposed to feel safe. In everyone’s eyes, it was my fault, and his friends joked about me. My whole life was ruined,” she said.
“No one knows or understands the feelings that someone like me is going through after it,” she said about being assaulted. “Students should be more educated in this type of seriousness and realize that it is an actual problem. I never thought that this would happen to me, but it did, and I didn’t know what to do.”