In an age where AI is quickly cementing its place in our society, replacing artists and writers alike, it is becoming almost a crucial skill for people to be able to detect whenever AI is being used in place of actual human effort. In a school setting, especially, where there has been a heavy uptick in students using AI for their schoolwork, it’s all the more important to be able to tell whose work is behind the screen. Do you know what to look out for when checking for signs of AI? Test your skills and see how accurate you really are.
The following test consists of ten general prompts that were fed into Chat-GPT, whose answers were thus recorded. Those same general prompts were sent out to West High as a survey to collect student responses. The aim of this test is to choose which you believe to be the AI-generated response compared to the one written by the student. Good luck!
(Note: The following responses may have been cut down for the sake of length and might not include the complete answer as provided by either the student or Chat-GPT.)
Bot or not?
There was an error. Please try again.
10 Total Questions
Test Complete
This test has ended.
Question 1/10
Should students be allowed to have phones at school? Make sure to choose the option you think was generated by the bot! (Student response provided by Harel Gameti '25)
Correct!
Incorrect
Question 1/10
Should students be allowed to have phones at school? Make sure to choose the option you think was generated by the bot! (Student response provided by Harel Gameti '25)
Your Answer
Correct Answer
I think it depends on a few factors. On one hand, having phones at school can be pretty distracting, especially if students are constantly checking social media or texting during class. But then again, phones can also be really useful tools for learning. They can help students look up information quickly, collaborate on projects, or even use educational apps. Plus, in emergencies, having a phone can be a lifeline for students to reach out to parents or guardians.
Your Answer
Phones have become a part of our society, work, economic, and political world. Having them out of high schools and colleges, in particular, would be rather far-fetched due to the technology these people are normally exposed to. Phones are also very distracting or addicting for students, causing them to periodically check their phones within 30-second intervals during or outside of class.
Your Answer
Question 2/10
Does school start too early? Make sure to choose the option you think was generated by the bot! (Student response provided by Harel Gameti '25)
Correct!
Incorrect
Question 2/10
Does school start too early? Make sure to choose the option you think was generated by the bot! (Student response provided by Harel Gameti '25)
Your Answer
Correct Answer
Personally, I think there's some merit to the argument that school starts too early for many students. Teenagers especially seem to struggle with early start times. Their bodies are wired to stay up later and sleep in, thanks to changes in their circadian rhythms during adolescence. There's actually been a fair bit of research suggesting that starting school later, say around 9 a.m. or so, could lead to better academic performance, improved attendance, and even reduced rates of depression among students.
Your Answer
A better question would be asking if school sessions last for too long since people typically wake up to work at around the same time students go to school. However, that question itself is rather similar to the original question because people with jobs or professions are often in working hours for longer than students. To note, an average day of school for a student is between 7 to 8 hours, what you could also call a "9 to 5" in working terms, also 8 hours. The difference between a "9 to 5" and the average school schedule is that hours are either pushed back or extended forward.
Your Answer
Question 3/10
Should healthy food cost less than junk food? Make sure to choose the option you think was generated by the bot! (Student response provided by Phoebe Ephraim-Gill' 25)
Correct!
Incorrect
Question 3/10
Should healthy food cost less than junk food? Make sure to choose the option you think was generated by the bot! (Student response provided by Phoebe Ephraim-Gill' 25)
Your Answer
Correct Answer
Absolutely, I think healthy food should be more affordable than junk food. It's a bit unfair that sometimes the cheapest options are the ones that are packed with sugar, salt, and unhealthy fats. This kind of pricing can make it really tough for people, especially those on tight budgets, to make nutritious choices for themselves and their families.
Your Answer
Absolutely. Health should be affordable, both food wise and healthcare wise. Obesity is a rapid problem in the United States, but most people don’t realize is the problem is the price of healthy food vs. junk food, not the will of the people. It also take time to prepare healthy food, and it perishes quicker. Not everyone has the privilege of affording time and affording to have food go bad.
Your Answer
Question 4/10
Are good guys or bad guys more interesting? Make sure to choose the option you think was generated by the bot! (Student response provided by Addison Long '25)
Correct!
Incorrect
Question 4/10
Are good guys or bad guys more interesting? Make sure to choose the option you think was generated by the bot! (Student response provided by Addison Long '25)
Your Answer
Correct Answer
I think it really depends on personal preference and the context of the story. Both good and bad characters can be incredibly compelling in their own ways. In many stories, it's the interplay between good and bad characters that really drives the plot forward and keeps us hooked. So, while both types of characters have their own allure, it's often the dynamic between them that makes a story truly captivating.
Your Answer
Both can be interesting depending on their backstories and motivations. Good guys' motivations and backstories are generally more developed, but villains' are often more interesting, leave more room for interpretation, and/or are more thematic for the narrative as a whole.
Your Answer
Question 5/10
Should audience members be able to film live concerts? Make sure to choose the option you think was generated by the bot! (Student response provided by Lily Zukin '24)
Correct!
Incorrect
Question 5/10
Should audience members be able to film live concerts? Make sure to choose the option you think was generated by the bot! (Student response provided by Lily Zukin '24)
Your Answer
Correct Answer
I think it's all about finding a balance that respects both the artists' creative rights and the fans' desire to capture and share their concert memories. As long as everyone's respectful of each other and mindful of the experience for everyone involved, I think there's room for both filming and enjoying live concerts.
Your Answer
Yes. I get the reason is that this is how the performers and theatre make money to have people come to the show and supporting artists is important and having videos maybe people won't buy as much. But some people can't afford to go to live concerts and the only way is bootlegs or other recordings people get at live shows. Maybe if there were official videos that people could get to after the live show so that people who can't get to the show can still enjoy parts of it, people would still go because there's a different feeling going to a live show than watching something on the internet.
Your Answer
Question 6/10
Is social media beneficial or harmful? Make sure to choose the option you think was generated by the bot! (Student response provided by Lincoln Beihl '25)
Correct!
Incorrect
Question 6/10
Is social media beneficial or harmful? Make sure to choose the option you think was generated by the bot! (Student response provided by Lincoln Beihl '25)
Your Answer
Correct Answer
Both? Like any tool, it can be used for good or for ill, depending on how it's wielded. The key is finding a healthy balance and being mindful of our own usage and the impact it has on ourselves and others.
Your Answer
Social media at its core is not meant to be harmful, instead marketed as a connecting software that allows for people to come together and share experiences. However, there certainly is a lot of dispute as to if this is truly the case. Cyber bullying and other problems can easily arise from such an expansive network of people and thus must be taken seriously by companies and users alike.
Your Answer
Question 7/10
Should physical education be required in schools? Make sure to choose the option you think was generated by the bot! (Student response provided by Harel Gameti '25)
Correct!
Incorrect
Question 7/10
Should physical education be required in schools? Make sure to choose the option you think was generated by the bot! (Student response provided by Harel Gameti '25)
Your Answer
Correct Answer
Absolutely. I think it's important for PE classes to be inclusive and accessible to all students, regardless of their abilities or interests. It's about promoting holistic well-being and helping kids develop the skills they need to lead healthy, active lives now and in the future.
Your Answer
Physical education should be required in schools for at least a trimester/semester, or another range of time since it can be considered a "health study", and is needed for students to understand ways to live a healthy lifestyle.
Your Answer
Question 8/10
How much should the public know about a celebrity’s personal life? Make sure to choose the option you think was generated by the bot! (Student response provided by Shannon Chen '27)
Correct!
Incorrect
Question 8/10
How much should the public know about a celebrity’s personal life? Make sure to choose the option you think was generated by the bot! (Student response provided by Shannon Chen '27)
Your Answer
Correct Answer
I think it's important for the media and the public to respect celebrities' boundaries and only delve into their personal lives to the extent that they're comfortable with. There's a fine line between healthy interest and invasive scrutiny, and it's crucial to err on the side of respect and empathy. After all, just because someone is famous doesn't mean they're not entitled to basic dignity and privacy.
Your Answer
The public should know only what the celebrity wants them to know. If a celebrity wants to tell their fans everything about themself, that's alright because it's what that celebrity chose to do. It's not okay to know more about someone's life than they want though.
Your Answer
Question 9/10
Is it better to listen to music while working, or to work in silence? Make sure to choose the option you think was generated by the bot! (Student response provided by Brayden Tolentino '26)
Correct!
Incorrect
Question 9/10
Is it better to listen to music while working, or to work in silence? Make sure to choose the option you think was generated by the bot! (Student response provided by Brayden Tolentino '26)
Your Answer
Correct Answer
It just depends on the situation. Sometimes music is great for getting me in the zone, and other times I just need some peace and quiet to get stuff done. It's all about finding the right balance for me.
Your Answer
Working in silence is the most effective and efficient way to get work done, your mind is set on one objective and that is to complete your work. When listening to music your mind may wonder off to people connected to the song, catchy lyrics, or more songs that sound similar.
Your Answer
Question 10/10
Are professional athletes paid too much? Make sure to choose the option you think was generated by the bot! (Student response provided by Harel Gameti '25)
Correct!
Incorrect
Question 10/10
Are professional athletes paid too much? Make sure to choose the option you think was generated by the bot! (Student response provided by Harel Gameti '25)
Your Answer
Correct Answer
While it might seem a bit excessive at times, I guess you could say that professional athletes are paid what the market dictates. Whether or not that's "too much" is really up for debate, I suppose.
Your Answer
This depends on the type of professional sport played. Professional athletes in sports with the mass majority of popularity will receive payments beneficial to most of their lifetime, while smaller professional athletes may still have to work 2-3 extra jobs in order to make a living.
Your Answer